What to Do When Leaders Don’t Lead: Wildfire Policy (or Lack Thereof) in 2020

Kerri Timmer

Kerri Timmer

Vice President, Climate & Energy

I’ve had a number of sleepless nights over the past few weeks. You might think it’s because of the COVID crisis, or the financial melt-down in our small Sierra towns, or the fires that are literally burning up the state right now. And you’d be right. But underlying all of that is the head-shaking, eye-popping, foot-stomping, heart-wrenching fact that our leaders don’t lead.

At the beginning of the recent conflagrations – with two of the largest fires in state history actively burning at the time – elected and appointed leaders in Sacramento failed to pass comprehensive climate/wildfire/drought/flood and economic recovery legislation this year. After letting two carefully crafted climate/wildfire bills die an ignominious death in committee, our elected and appointed leaders failed their constituents again by ignoring a hail-Mary attempt by concerned colleagues to pass an emergency measure to deal with just the wildfire piece, because… wildfires!

2020 has been an astounding year for wildfire. According to the CALFIRE website, accessed on Sept. 9, 2020, some 1.66 million acres burned between Jan. 1 and Aug. 30 this year. I’ve heard figures as high as 2.3 to 2.5 million acres in early September media reports. To put either figure into context, last year at this time fewer than 30,000 acres had burned. And the 5-year average for the same interval (January through August) is 309,675 acres.

Much of this destruction had already taken place as legislators and Administration officials were nearing the end of the legislative session in late August. Yet they chose to put more lives, businesses, and property at risk, along with wildlife, recreation areas, and even critical resources like clean drinking water and reliable electricity, by failing to act. People worked together for two years helping to craft two different bills – AB 3256 and SB 45 – to address climate change and its impact on fire, water, and our communities. The primary opposition to these bills? The funding mechanism: selling bonds that get paid back by California taxpayers over time.

I’ve heard the argument that certain legislators don’t want to “burden” their children with bond debt. But I guess they don’t mind burdening their children with the aftermath of these large, damaging mega-fires that are changing life as we know it in California and other western states. We didn’t get into this dire situation overnight; it’s going to take time and long-term investment to work our way out of it. And who benefits from that? Today’s young people, who – if we do our job right today – will have communities where they can work, homes where they can live, and places where they can go for recreation and solitude in the future.

How do we find ourselves in this situation? When I listen to my worse angels, I’d say a pathetic, petty, argumentative, ego-driven lack of leadership, resulting from a shocking inability to set aside personal feelings in order to address life-and-death issues for constituents. There are lots of opinions about how the forests got to be in the state they’re in; but how our so-called leaders could choose not to act now – to do something, anything, to help the situation – is beyond me.

Like many people, I seem to be spending half my days making sure I’m ready to go in an emergency, tracking fire updates to be sure friends and family are ok, and reading more and more headlines and seeing more and more photos about the devastation across our state. The end of a legislative session is never pretty; but it is frustrating and infuriating to see tweets coming out of the Administration suggesting that we “must do more” around climate and wildfire, when these very same officials and many of their elected counterparts sat on their hands just a short couple of weeks ago when they might have been able to do something to help.

It’s hard to know what we can do as individuals to change the situation in Sacramento. But one thing I know for sure, we need to hold our leaders accountable for such systemic failure. Write a letter, make a phone call. Let your elected and appointed leaders know your thoughts. And please, if you do nothing else… VOTE!

Read More Recent Blogs

Understanding our Vulnerabilities—And Our Choices—in the Sierra

Sierra CAMP, a program of Sierra Business Council, is currently undertaking a regional vulnerability assessment to examine how Sierra Nevada communities will be affected by projected climate changes. We have already seen the massive impact that climate change can have in its multiple forms on our communities in the mountains. Climate change leaves our homes and businesses vulnerable to wildfire and floods, it impacts the clarity of our lakes and rivers, and challenges our recreation patterns as we navigate the changes in snow and temperature year round. The goal of the vulnerability assessment is to better understand and measure the impacts of climate change on our social and economic systems that are inextricably linked to our natural environment.

2020 Impact Statement

Over the course of the last year, the impact of COVID-19 has snowballed into a deep recession and shifted the course of life as we know it. Over the course of the last year, the impact of COVID-19 has snowballed into a deep recession and shifted the course of life as we know it.

Fragile Like a Bomb… How RBG Inspired Me

I’m wearing my RBG T-shirt and staring at my RBG action figure, gifts from my daughter, a true social justice warrior. Like me, she was raised to revere and honor women like Ruth Bader Ginsberg. It is a family tradition that follows at least four generations that I know of and we hold closely a favorite RBG quote, “What is the difference between a bookkeeper in the Garment District and a Supreme Court justice? … One generation.”

More by this author

Capitol Building MG 1600 Sans watermark

SBC’s 2019 Legislative Outlook for the Sierra

The new 2019-2020 legislative session is officially underway. This means SBC’s Government Affairs team, under Chris Mertens’ astute leadership, is busy reviewing bill introductions, gathering information from partners and legislative staff, and identifying priority legislation for engagement by SBC and our coalition groups and colleagues.